By David N. Butterworth
The winner of 2004’s Academy Award® for Best Documentary Feature, Zana
Briski and Ross Kauffman’s Born into Brothels isn’t nearly as
prurient an experience as you might expect from a movie focusing on the plight
of young children growing up in the notorious red light district of India’s
Sonagachi, a highly impoverished section of Calcutta.
That’s partly because of the kids themselves, on whom the filmmakers mostly
concentrate, not their fallen mothers trapped by the unavoidable scourge of “The
Line,” an inevitable life of prostitution with little if anything to prevent
their hapless daughters, some not quite teenagers already, following in their
ill-fated footsteps. Strangely enough the eight featured children–Avijit, Gour,
Kochi, Manik, Puja, Shanti, Suchitra, and Tapasi–are vibrantly alive, many
with hopes of escaping the slums and securing an all-important education no
matter how fanciful, how impossible it might sound. (Their fathers, if they’re
even still alive, are invariably drug addicts, strung out on hashish.)
The kids talk openly and unsentimentally about their lives. “The men who
enter the building are not so good,” comments one. They work hard tending
house–cooking, cleaning dishes, and babysitting siblings. As a result they are
mature beyond their years–older and very much the wiser.
Born into Brothels is all about second chances and the opportunity
here has been provided in the form of a simple Western tool that many of us take
for granted: a point-and-shoot camera. Briski and Kauffman, the former of whom
appears on film and works side-by-side with the children, ask the kids of
Sonagachi to tell their own story in words and (mostly) pictures through the
construct of a basic photography class and the results are often mesmerizing,
with the children–who range in age from ten to fourteen–possessing
incredible and heretofore untapped natural talent.
Briski’s original goal was to live and work among the prostitutes,
capturing the sordid surroundings and conditions that front their illegal
activities on film (no easy task to be sure). But she was instantly drawn to the
children and quickly changed her approach. In that regard she breaks the
cardinal rule of documentary filmmaking by actually getting involved in the
children’s lives, attempting to register them for boarding school, for
example, and influencing some of their decision making, such as securing a visa
and other travel documents for the 11-year-old Avijit so that he can journey to
Amsterdam to participate in a World Press Photo Foundation exhibit.
In that regard we are afforded many opportunities to witness Calcutta’s
incomprehensible bureaucracy, as Zana Auntie (as the kids call Briski) battles
stubborn government officials and their endless red tape.
What unfolds, however, is a film that, despite its scurrilous subject matter,
remains genuinely uplifting and inspiring. Whereas not every child introduced in
the film is assured a happy ending, Born into Brothels paints a vivid
portrait of the vibrancy of human life no matter how squalid its environment and
reinforces the oft-held notion that one person can make a difference.